HA: A3500 vs. FC/AL

[Steve Bulmer]

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------30D5062520294132C180B388
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Just a forewarning; since the card and thus the
cached data lives on the server (not the storage) a
system crash could potentially mean that your
application thought the write was complete but it
never actually made it to disk.  I was *told* by
a Sun engineer that the fast write card is not
supported in Sun clusters for this reason.

You should note that the fast write cache card
when ordered actually comes with 2 cards so
the cache is mirrored and protected in case of
just a cache card failure.

In terms of fast write cache in the A5x00 I do not
know of any, I would have to check my books. Your
document sounds like it has more info than I do. I
know there was some limited cache in the older SSAs
like 100's 110's 200's etc.

And yes, the fwcadm comes as part of the software you
get with the fast write cache cards.

Steve

"Beck, Joe" wrote:

> Was this potential for lost/corrupted data just a forewarning or did you
> experience problems?
> Very curious as we are suppossed to start running performance tests in our
> environment (large OPS, read intensive app)--trying to decide whether it
> behooves us to look into fast write cache for our A5000's & A5200's.
> Also, I was told that even w/out a fast write cache controllers there was a
> way to turn on fast write cache on the Array itself.
> Do you know if this is true? or is this capability availability at both
> levels?
> I recently received a document sun storedge fast write cache best practices,
> so i guess that's a good starting point.
> one thing i noticed is a fwcadm command which must be part of a package that
> comes with the controller?
> Any feedback on this topic is appreciated
>
> ______________________________________________________
> Joe Beck        Unix Administrator/Tax Redesign Project
> jbeck@dol.state.nj.us
> voice:  (609)292-5785
>
> The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet. -Aristotle
>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: Steve Bulmer [SMTP:bulmer@theALLIEDgroup.com]
> > Sent: Monday, January 10, 2000 11:12 AM
> > To:   Seth Rothenberg
> > Cc:   ssa-managers@Eng.Auburn.EDU
> > Subject:      Re: HA: A3500 vs. FC/AL
> >
> > The only supported way to have 3 Sun hosts connected
> > to 2 Sun storage arrays is to use Sun A5200 technology and
> > direct connect the computers to the arrays WITHOUT hubs.
> > This is the only way Sun will support more than 2 servers connected
> > to fibre channel disks. Their 3 and 4 node Sun clusters must be con-
> > figured this way.
> >
> > You *might* consider using the fast write cache controllers for the
> > Suns (they are SBUS cards) if you go to the A5200 solution but be
> > aware that this is not a good idea for failover or Oracle Parallel Svr
> > as data can be lost/corrupted in cases of host failure.
> >
> > As for the need for cache, it helps most in small I/O, random, mostly
> > write
> > intensive applications and less as you move toward larger, sequential read
> > intensive applications.
> >
> > Steve
> >
> > Seth Rothenberg wrote:
> >
> > > SSA Managers, Help !
> > > I have spent the past month with my Sun Sales rep
> > > designing an HA system using two Enterprise 4500's and
> > > one A3500, 2x2 "Lite+" configuration.  Now, my boss says
> > > we need a third host.   So, I asked about the A3500FC.
> > > My Sales/Tech said the 3500FC control module only has
> > > one FC (is that per controller?), and therefore, it is not a "loop",
> > > but really a "hub".  The Sales/Tech did not know if we can
> > > install 3 hosts and 2 controllers using 2 hubs.
> > >
> > > IF A3500 does not support 3 hosts, another idea is to just
> > > get two A5200's, which really can do a loop.
> > > However, we give up the Controller Module.
> > > We need to evaluate whether the Read/Write Cache in the
> > > controller can be sacrificed.  My impression is yes.  I suspect
> > > my boss won't agree.
> > >
> > > The A5200's also have hubs.  I would be interested in
> > > whether anyone has one of these configurations.
> > >
> > > Thanks
> > > Seth
> >  << File: bulmer.vcf >>

--------------30D5062520294132C180B388
Content-Type: text/x-vcard; charset=us-ascii;
 name="bulmer.vcf"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Description: Card for Steve Bulmer
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="bulmer.vcf"

begin:vcard 
n:Bulmer;Steven
tel;pager:(860) 922-3324
tel;cell:(860) 922-3324
tel;fax:(860) 815-0009
tel;work:(860) 815-0019
x-mozilla-html:TRUE
url:www.thealliedgroup.com
org:SNS
version:2.1
email;internet:bulmer@theALLIEDgroup.com
title:Director of Technology
adr;quoted-printable:;;628 Hebron Ave Bldg #2=0D=0AP.O. Box 1336;Glastonbury;CT;06033;USA
x-mozilla-cpt:;7168
fn:Steven Bulmer
end:vcard

--------------30D5062520294132C180B388--